Skip to content

Open enrollment for 2027: enroll by December 15 for a January 1 start. See dates

Wiswell Insurance

ICHRA vs group health insurance: which fits your Colorado business?

By Pete Wiswell

A small business owner reviewing benefits paperwork

Most small business owners we talk with want the same three things: a predictable cost, coverage their team values and as little paperwork as possible. In Colorado there are two main ways to get there, an Individual Coverage HRA (ICHRA) or a traditional group plan. Here is how to think about the choice.

Choose an ICHRA if predictable cost matters most

With an ICHRA you set a fixed monthly allowance, often equal to the lowest-cost Silver plan, and each employee picks the individual plan that fits their family. Your cost is the allowance plus a platform fee of about $15 to $30 and a broker fee of about $15 to $25 per employee per month. Colorado's individual market has strong options, which is why ICHRAs often save money here.

Choose a group plan if your team needs PPO access

Every plan offered through an ICHRA is an individual market HMO plan. If your employees travel often, have specialists outside one hospital system or simply want a PPO, a traditional group plan is usually the better fit, though the broader network usually costs more.

Check the group plan requirements

  • At least one full-time, unrelated W-2 employee who will enroll
  • The benefit offered to all full-time employees
  • An employer contribution of at least 50% of employee-only premium
  • A business domiciled in Colorado

Remember the tax credit trade-off

Employees offered a group ICHRA cannot receive state premium tax credits. If several of your employees would qualify for large credits on their own, factor that in when you set the allowance.

Still deciding? Send Pete your client questionnaire and group census from the employer quote page and he will model both options for your team.

Talk with a Wiswell broker

There is no cost to work with us. Tell us what you need and we will walk you through every option.